Money rarely speaks as loudly and personally as it did for Tom
Golisano, a billionaire who appears to have been the principal force in pushing the Democrats out
of power in Albany, after he was snubbed by the party to which he has
been a principal patron. And rarely has a good government advocate
shown so clearly that he doesn't even know what government ethics is.
It should come as little surprise to people involved in local
government that a New York
Times article about
bullying among ten- and eleven-year-olds has a great deal of relevance.
I said for years about my town's government that its major participants
were like ten-year-old boys on a playground, taunting, playing games of
intimidation, spreading false rumors, keeping communal secrets,
excluding
whoever doesn't go along, and staying loyal to those in control so that
they aren't excluded themselves
In the midst of a big corruption probe, a pair of back-and-forth ethics
complaints filed with a nearly toothless ethics commission in El Paso
doesn't seem like much. But it does sheds some light on how much El
Paso government is about the players rather than the citizens. And it
touches on some issues that are important everywhere, including the use
of lawsuits to cripple ethics commissions, legal fees for ethics
defense, local government attorney conflicts, and city-county relations.
Nothing is more important to an ethics program than ensuring that an
ethics commission is seen as independent, and not a pawn of
politicians. People will not trust the advisory opinions and enforcement decisions of an
ethics commission consisting of people with even presumed ties to politicians. Since trust is the principal goal of an ethics program,
this is unacceptable.
Maricopa County (home of Phoenix) is doing an excellent job of showing
America's local governments what not to do. In April, I wrote about the conflict
that existed when the county attorney, after representing the county
board of supervisors as it put together plans and contracts for a new
county courthouse, decided to investigate the board's handling of these
plans and contracts. The outcry over this conflict led the county
attorney to turn the investigation over to another county.
Updates below
Anyone who doubts the need for truly independent ethics commissions
need look no further than what has been happening in Philadelphia this
week. Or should I say "this year"?
I am always fascinated at the ways in which even the most reform-minded
politicians can kill ethics reform proposals that might cause them some
embarrassment. Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana has done a great deal for
ethics reform, but at least one reform bill, which on its face seems
pretty minor, has apparently gotten in his craw.
According to an
article in today's Boston Globe,
former Massachusetts Speaker of the House Sal DiMasi was indicted by a
federal grand jury on a variety of public corruption charges (see my
blog posts on DiMasi's